Calculator comparisons
Best Free Retirement Calculators in 2026
Eight free retirement calculators, compared on what actually matters: tax modeling, withdrawal sequencing, and ease of use. We gave competitors credit where they earned it, because a rigged comparison helps nobody. Full disclosure: we make NestCalc, one of the tools below.
Updated October 2026 · 10 min read
The short version
- Best for planning depth: Boldin (formerly NewRetirement). Free Basic plan for the overview; $144/year PlannerPlus adds Monte Carlo and a serious Roth conversion explorer.
- Best for seeing everything in one place: Empower Personal Dashboard. Free account aggregation with a solid planner attached. Expect a sales call about advisory services.
- Best for FIRE: cFIREsim (free, open source) for historical backtesting, or ProjectionLab's free tier for visual planning.
- Best for a quick check: Fidelity's readiness tool or Vanguard's nest egg calculator. Fast, simple, no depth.
- Best withdrawal sequencing under $20: NestCalc. No account required, 1,000 Monte Carlo simulations free, and a $19 one-time unlock gets the year-by-year plan showing which account to tap, with Roth conversions, ACA, and IRMAA modeled.
How we compared them
We scored each tool on five things that separate a real plan from a pretty chart:
- Tax modeling. Year-by-year federal tax estimates, or a flat assumed rate? The best handle brackets, RMDs, and Roth conversions.
- Withdrawal sequencing. Does it say which account to tap each year, or just hand you a success percentage?
- Simulation quality. Monte Carlo or historical backtesting beats a single assumed return, because markets do not deliver 7% every year.
- Free depth. How much of the good stuff is actually free versus gated behind a subscription?
- Friction and privacy. Can you use it without an account or bank logins?
The comparison at a glance
| Tool | Free Monte Carlo | Acct required | Fee | Key premium features | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| NestCalc | 1,000 scenarios | No | $19 one-time | Year-by-year withdrawal plan, Roth/ACA/IRMAA modeling, premium PDF | |
| Vanguard | 5,000 scenarios | No | None | N/A, fully free | Simple inputs only, no Social Security modeling |
| Empower | Yes ("thousands") | Yes | 0.89%/yr advisory (min $100K) | Human advisor; planning tools stay free | Advisory upsell funnel |
| ProjectionLab | Yes (count not published) | No | $129/yr | Saved plans, tax tools, Roth modeling, compare mode | Free plans don't save |
| Fidelity | Basic: no; deeper tool: yes | No for basic | None | N/A | 6-question readiness score |
| Boldin | No | Yes | $144/yr ($168/yr from Oct 15) | 1,000-scenario MC, Roth Conversion Explorer, 10 scenarios, account linking | |
| FIREcalc | Historical backtesting | No | None | N/A, fully free | Not Monte Carlo |
| cFIREsim | Historical backtesting | No | None | N/A, fully free | Open source, not Monte Carlo |
Boldin (formerly NewRetirement): best for planning depth
Boldin is the heavyweight. Its free Basic plan covers income, assets, Social Security, and a long-range projection. The PlannerPlus tier ($144/year, rising to $168/year for new subscribers from October 15, 2026; 14-day trial) unlocks the serious machinery: Monte Carlo analysis, a Roth Conversion Explorer that optimizes against tax and IRMAA thresholds, account linking, and up to 10 side-by-side scenarios.
Where it wins: nothing free touches its input depth. Complicated situations (rental income, pensions, staggered retirements, estate goals) are what it was built for, and the Roth Conversion Explorer is excellent.
Where it falls short: Monte Carlo and Roth optimization, the two features most people want, require PlannerPlus. It needs an account and has a learning curve.
Empower Personal Dashboard: best for seeing everything in one place
Empower (formerly Personal Capital) is free and its killer feature is aggregation: link your bank, brokerage, and retirement accounts and see net worth, asset allocation, and fees in one dashboard. The retirement planner on top runs scenarios with different retirement dates and Social Security strategies.
Where it wins: no other free tool keeps your balances live and your plan in the same place. If your problem is accounts everywhere and no single view, start here.
Where it falls short: the business model is the catch. Empower sells wealth management, so expect advisory outreach. Roth modeling is basic, and the planner is shallower on year-by-year tax sequencing.
FIREcalc and cFIREsim: best for quick FIRE checks
These two are community institutions in the financial independence world. FIREcalc is the simplest: enter spending, portfolio, and years, get a success rate from historical market sequences. cFIREsim is its more flexible, open-source sibling, with more spending models and more knobs. Both are completely free.
Where they win: speed and honesty. No account, no upsell, no onboarding. For the core FIRE question ("can I retire on this portfolio?"), historical backtesting is arguably more trustworthy than Monte Carlo with assumed returns.
Where they fall short: taxes are thin. Neither does year-by-year tax modeling, Roth conversion optimization, or withdrawal sequencing. They answer "will the money last," not "how do I pull it out smartly."
ProjectionLab: best visual planner for FIRE
ProjectionLab is the modern favorite of the FIRE community: a visual, interactive timeline of your financial life with Monte Carlo simulation and historical backtesting. The free Basic tier runs the full engine but does not save your plan between sessions. Premium at $129/year adds saving, tax tools, Roth conversion modeling, and compare mode.
Where it wins: planning feels intuitive in a way spreadsheets never do. For visual thinkers mapping early retirement with career breaks or part-time work, it is the most pleasant tool here.
Where it falls short: the free tier is effectively a demo, since nothing persists. It is FIRE-flavored throughout; traditional retirees focused on RMDs and IRMAA may prefer Boldin or NestCalc.
Fidelity and Vanguard: best quick readiness checks
Both brokerages offer free calculators. Fidelity's readiness tool gives you a score and projection in minutes. Vanguard's nest egg calculator is even simpler: savings, years, returns, answer. Neither requires an account.
Where they win: zero friction. A five-minute gut check before deciding whether deeper planning is worth it.
Where they fall short: depth, by design. No withdrawal sequencing, no Roth conversion modeling, no ACA or IRMAA awareness. Treat the score as a starting point, not a plan.
NestCalc: best withdrawal sequencing under $20 (this site)
The straight version, since we built it. NestCalc is free with no account required, and the free tier runs 1,000 Monte Carlo simulations on your numbers. A $19 one-time unlock adds the year-by-year plan sequencing withdrawals across taxable, traditional, and Roth accounts to minimize lifetime taxes, with Roth conversion modeling, ACA subsidy cliff awareness, and IRMAA thresholds built in. Every recommendation comes with a plain-English explanation.
Where it wins: no other tool at this price gives you year-by-year withdrawal sequencing plus Roth, ACA, and IRMAA modeling with no account and no subscription. If your question is "which account do I tap each year and why," that is what it was built for.
Where it falls short: no account linking, so you type in balances (Empower wins there). No estate planning or 100-input scenarios (Boldin's paid tier wins there). A focused calculator, not a full dashboard.
Which calculator should you use?
- Just curious if you are on track: Fidelity or Vanguard, five minutes, done.
- Retiring early: cFIREsim for the community-standard check, ProjectionLab's free tier for the visual version.
- One dashboard for everything you own: Empower (ignore the advisory sales calls).
- Complex situation, willing to pay: Boldin PlannerPlus at $144/year.
- Year-by-year withdrawal and tax plan, $19 one-time, no account: NestCalc.
- Want to be thorough: use two. Pair an aggregator or backtester with a tax-aware planner and compare answers.
Get your year-by-year withdrawal plan
NestCalc runs 1,000 market simulations on your numbers free, no account required. A $19 one-time unlock builds your tax-optimized withdrawal sequence, Roth conversion schedule, and plain-English strategy notes.
Run the free calculator →Frequently asked questions
Are free retirement calculators accurate?
The math in most free calculators is sound. The bigger question is what they model. A simple calculator that ignores taxes, RMDs, and withdrawal sequencing can give a clean-looking answer that is thousands of dollars off your real outcome. The best free calculators run Monte Carlo simulations, model federal taxes year by year, and show which accounts to draw from. Inputs matter too: optimistic return assumptions produce optimistic answers no matter how good the engine is.
What is the best free alternative to Boldin (formerly NewRetirement)?
It depends on what you used Boldin for. For withdrawal sequencing and tax modeling with no account, NestCalc is the closest alternative at a $19 one-time unlock (the core simulation is free). For visual FIRE-style planning, ProjectionLab's free tier is strong. For historical backtesting, cFIREsim is free and open source. And Boldin's free Basic plan still exists, so you can keep using that without PlannerPlus.
Do I need to link my bank and brokerage accounts to use a retirement calculator?
No. Several good calculators, including NestCalc, FIREcalc, cFIREsim, and Fidelity's readiness tool, work entirely on numbers you type in. Account linking (offered by Empower and Boldin's paid tier) saves data entry and keeps balances fresh, but it is a convenience, not a requirement. If privacy matters to you, pick a tool that works without linking.
What is the catch with free retirement calculators?
Usually one of three things. Some gate the best features (Monte Carlo, Roth modeling, account linking) behind a paid tier, like Boldin and ProjectionLab. Some are marketing funnels: Empower's free dashboard is excellent, but expect outreach about their advisory service. And some are passion projects, like cFIREsim: free and excellent, but updated sporadically. Read the tradeoff, then pick the one whose catch bothers you least.
Should I use more than one retirement calculator?
Yes, and it is cheap since the good ones are free. No single calculator models everything, so cross-checking catches blind spots. A practical combo: one aggregator (Empower) for live net worth, one deep planner (Boldin's free tier or NestCalc) for withdrawal sequencing and taxes, and one backtester (cFIREsim) for a second opinion on success rates.